2022_영어발표와토론

[Check 11] Arrange these example arguments according to the steps given above. ■ Negative Constructive Speeches Negative constructive speeches present basic arguments against the motion. ■ Rebuttal Speeches Each team responds to the other team’s presentation and restates its own best arguments. [ 1 ] We oppose the notion that stricter plastic waste regulations are the best solution. [ ] To summarize, we worry about how strict plastic waste rules could affect the economy and lead to unintended problems. [ ] Stricter rules might burden small businesses, risking job losses and economic difficulties. [ ] Credible sources suggest that strict regulations could fuel illegal waste disposal. 1. State your team’s disagreement with what the affirmative speakers said. 2. Present persuasive arguments (evidence, logic, source citations) that refute the motion. 3. Demonstrate the harms or disadvantages that would result if the motion were adopted. 4. Summarize the negative arguments. Organization 1. Present additional research as needed to discredit the opposing team’s arguments. 2. Defend your arguments against your opponent’s attacks. 3. Point out arguments that the opposing team “ignored” or did not respond to adequately. 4. End the rebuttal with a strong final statement in which you restate your position and say that the other team failed to prove its case. Organization 18 I Getting Ready